All news articles

Milburn review proposes interview feedback for under-25s at large employers

A proposal in Alan Milburn’s review would require large employers to give meaningful feedback to unsuccessful applicants under 25, addressing jobseekers’ complaints that they are often left without a reply or guidance.

AI-generated editorial illustration based on the published article topic; not a documentary photograph.
Loading statistics…

UK jobseekers say being ignored after applying or interviewing leaves them without the guidance they need to improve, as a government-commissioned review proposes requiring large employers to give unsuccessful applicants under 25 meaningful feedback.

The recommendation is part of former minister Alan Milburn’s review of young people not in employment, education or training. Its proposals, aimed mainly at England, seek to reduce the share of young people in that position from 13% to about 5% by 2036; the review says Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland should adapt the principles to their own systems.

For applicants, even a reply would be welcome. Yugraj Samrai, 23, from Coventry, says he has submitted hundreds of applications since graduating with a marketing degree in July and hears nothing back 30% to 40% of the time. “I understand there are very few graduate jobs available, but at least give me a response to say whether I’ll progress onto the next stage or not,” he told the BBC.

Ffion Johns, 24, from Llanelli, says she sent 70 applications before getting an interview in September. She has been unemployed since June and says she has been left without feedback about why she did not get jobs, including after interviews. “With most of these roles I’m not getting a rejection. I’m just not hearing anything,” she said.

A survey by recruitment firm Robert Walters last year found that 86% of UK job hunters said their applications had been ignored, with no response from the hiring organisation. Milburn’s review says the silence can be particularly difficult for young people, who may invest time and emotional effort in applications without learning from the outcome.

Can employers respond to everyone?

Employers say they face a high volume of applications in a competitive jobs market. The BBC also reports that artificial intelligence is helping applicants submit large numbers of applications, adding to the pressure on recruiters.

Career coach Meg Burton says employers should at least tell applicants when they have been unsuccessful. She says AI could help with that, while people who reach interview stage should receive pointers on why they were not selected and what they could learn. The feedback need not be extensive, she says.

Jessica Anderson, 21, from Swindon, told the BBC that applying can take hours, making it worse when employers do not acknowledge the effort. Ellie McCrone, 20, said constructive feedback is preferable to being ignored: “You can’t fix something unless you know what the problem is.”

The review’s proposal concerns meaningful feedback for unsuccessful applicants under 25 at large employers. Whether the government adopts it, and how employers would manage the workload, remain unresolved. In the meantime, Burton advises applicants to tailor their CVs, follow up politely when a promised response is late and seek help with applications.

Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.

From the discussion

Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.

Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.

Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.

Loading comments…